I do not typically like to read, and when I am given a reading assignment, I dread it and put it off as late as I can. However, this book made me change my mind. I didn’t put it off until last-minute, and decided to give it a try. I really enjoyed reading this book. I did not feel like I was just reading boring material on the same thing “what to do and not do with your students”. All of the information from Chapters 1 and 2 was helpful. The author has some wonderful strategies to use to help students become engaged in writing in their writing notebooks. I too find myself struggling sometimes to find something to write about at times, and these strategies have helped me, as well as I know it will help my students when they do not know what to write about. I agree with the author, and feel that after you have presented your students with various ways to write in their writer’s notebook, it is okay to let them start writing all by themselves. If you are always giving students a prompt or topic to write about, you will never learn anything new and students will not be given a chance to write what they want. For example, if a student wanted to write about something that happened over the weekend that was really cool, and they are given a prompt, they will not be as excited to write, thus not writing well.
I feel there are many purposeful reasons for a Writer’s Notebook. First and foremost, I feel it is a great way for children to express their thoughts and experiences on paper. For students who struggle talking in front of others or are very shy, writing in a notebook is a great way to get them talking. It is a great way to help students not forget ideas, experiences, memories, etc. I was required to write in a Writer’s Notebook my eight grade year in Social Studies and Language Arts. In Social Studies we were not required to write about anything in particular, just what we wanted to write about. However, in Language Arts, we were given a prompt, like “tell me what you are doing this weekend”. I did not like that because if I did not have anything planned for the weekend, my entry was pretty short and boring. I wanted to write about something I found interesting and exciting. In Social Studies class though, I got to write about things that I enjoyed. Because I got to write about things that I liked, I kept the notebook and still occasionally read it. I like going back and looking at things I wrote and things I did. I couldn’t even tell you where my Language Arts Notebook is.
A Writer’s Notebook also helps students start writing; really writing. Just writing down your spelling words or answers to questions in a textbook is not writing. When I was in Elementary School, I was most happiest when I got to write. I absolutely loved to write. Writing fictional stories using my imagination and creativeness was so much fun. Unfortunately, schools have become more textbook driven, and fail to give students enough time to write and be creative. Students have so many thoughts and ideas they want to get out, but may not be allowed time to do so. Writing in a notebook helps students get their ideas out on paper.
My goals as a teacher of writing, is simple. Let my students write. I do not want my students to groan and moan when they hear it is time to get out our Writer’s Notebook. I want them to be waiting for me to say it, and then when I do, rush to get their notebooks and begin writing with a smile on their face. But in reality, not all students are going to be excited about writing. It is my job to help those students who do not like to write, become better writers and maybe enjoy it in the process. I remember that when my teacher would give me writing prompts, that I really could not relate to, I struggled to get anything down on paper. I think it is good to get to know your students, and when you get to know their likes, dislikes, interests, hobbies, etc., you can begin to help them write about things they do enjoy, which will get them more excited about writing. Giving them a prompt about their favorite ice cream and why may not be the best choice for a student who has never eaten ice cream or dislikes ice cream. Get to know your students. This will be beneficial to you and your students.
Getting a Writer’s Notebook started may be the hardest part of the writing process. Students may have had not so great experiences with Writing Notebooks in earlier grades, and may have mixed feelings about them. I think that the author of Notebook Know-How has some great strategies for getting the notebook started. I like the idea of getting them started with some strategies about what to write, and them letting them do their own thing. Read a story to them and then relate the story to their own lives. This will help them discover things to write about that they would have never discovered without the help of a simple story. It could even be a picture book. I have always heard that readers make the best writers.

Me writing at age 3.